- Startup Stoic
- Posts
- Why American Eagle’s “Great Jeans” Ad Sparked Drama...and a Stock Surge
Why American Eagle’s “Great Jeans” Ad Sparked Drama...and a Stock Surge
The Sydney Sweeney “Great Genes/Jeans” Blur
In partnership with
American Eagle’s July 2025 campaign starring Sydney Sweeney leaned into a cheeky pun: “Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans”—initially written as “genes” and struck through to reveal “jeans.” In one video, Sweeney intones:
“Genes are passed down… My jeans are blue.”
American Eagle Jeans campaign
The ad evoked a nostalgic callback to Brooke Shields’s controversial 1980 Calvin Klein spot—before igniting massive backlash. It quickly became a viral case study in how cultural context can transform marketing.
The Controversy: What Went Wrong
The “Genes” Pun Fell Flat
Critics argued the campaign implied that Sydney’s attractiveness was genetically superior—hinting at race, appearance, and inherited traits in a way that felt exclusionary.Celebrity Alignment Sparked Questions
Past photos of Sweeney’s family events showing MAGA themes resurfaced. Combined with her apolitical stance, some audiences saw the campaign as tone-deaf for Gen Z values.The Visual Aesthetic Felt Dated
From its heavy callback to the 1980 Brooke Shields Calvin Klein ad, many labeled it retro in the wrong way—oversexualized and out of touch with today’s conversations around representation.
Find your customers on Roku this Black Friday
As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.
Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.
Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.
Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.
American Eagle’s Response
In response to the uproar, American Eagle issued a statement,
Response to the controversy
They clarified the brand's intent was playful, not political or ideological. AE reaffirmed its commitment to inclusion and stated the ad "was never meant to be about anything but jeans."
Some critics viewed this as dismissive. Others appreciated the straightforwardness. Either way, AE did not apologize — and stood by the campaign.
The Unexpected Outcome
Despite the backlash, the campaign delivered outsized results:
Stock Surge: American Eagle’s stock price jumped nearly 15% over the week, adding ~$400M in market value.
Sales Spike: Denim sales reportedly spiked 23% in 72 hours post-launch.
4B+ Impressions: It became a full-blown cultural moment—memes, remixes, hot takes, and think pieces included.
American Eagle leaned into the moment without retreating—removing some clips, but letting the core campaign continue.
What Startups Should Learn
1. A Word Can Change the Message
Even one word—especially one as loaded as “genes”—can hijack your narrative. Test creative concepts across diverse perspectives before going live.
2. Standing Firm vs. Being Stubborn
AE didn’t apologize. They clarified. That decision served them commercially, but startups need to read the room carefully—especially if community trust is still forming.
3. Earned Media Can Beat Paid
The backlash drove hundreds of millions in free press. Risky campaigns can massively amplify your reach—but they must be deliberate, not accidental.
4. Know Your Spokespeople’s Shadow
Celebrities carry history, affiliations, and subtext. Make sure your values align—or that you're ready to handle the consequences if they don't.
5. Attention ≠ Loyalty
AE gained eyeballs and dollars—but also fractured parts of its audience. Startups must ask: Are you courting a temporary spike, or long-term trust?
TL;DR Summary
Element | What AE Did | Startup Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
Creative Direction | "Genes/Jeans" wordplay | Clever ≠ Clear; puns need audience testing |
Public Response | “It’s about jeans, not genes.” | Clarify quickly, don’t deflect blindly |
Brand Positioning | Leaned into cultural controversy | Confidence works—if brand trust exists |
Result | Sales + stock value surged | Risk can reward—but should be intentional |
Final Thought
AE’s campaign reminds us:
You don’t always control how people receive your message.
You only control how well you prepare, respond, and stay aligned with your mission.
So when you craft your next campaign, ask:
Are we being smart—or just loud?
Are we ready to own all interpretations?
Do we know when to stand our ground—and when to pivot?
More Inspirational Stories…
Until next time—
— Team Startup Stoic