Ketchup, Deception & Brand Loyalty: How Heinz Turned a Problem Into Prime Time Branding

In partnership with

Let’s face it: brand loyalty isn’t what it used to be. Today’s consumers switch fast. But Heinz—yes, the ketchup giant—recently showed us how brand loyalty can be reinforced… not by begging for attention, but by boldly calling out betrayal.

In a cheeky, sharp, and surprisingly strategic campaign, Heinz tackled what it dubbed “Ketchup Fraud”—when restaurants fill Heinz bottles with cheaper ketchup but keep the branding.

Instead of responding with lawsuits or quiet compliance, Heinz did something brilliant.

The Problem: Ketchup Fraud Is Real

Heinz found that many restaurants reuse Heinz bottles but refill them with cheaper ketchup—to capitalize on the brand's strong reputation without paying for it.

For most brands, this would be frustrating.
For Heinz? It was an opportunity.

The Campaign: Bold. Playful. On-Brand.

Heinz launched a multi-channel campaign to expose this behavior with humor and control. Their approach included:

• Playful Print Ads:
  Close-up shots of generic ketchup pretending to be Heinz, with the line:
  “Even we can’t tell the difference from the outside.”

• Social Media & UGC Angle:
  Heinz invited real customers to report ketchup fraud in restaurants.
  The reward? A year’s supply of real Heinz ketchup.

• Clear Messaging:
  Instead of sounding alarmed, Heinz leaned into its confidence and cultural dominance, positioning itself as the ketchup of record.

Why This Worked So Well

Here’s why this campaign deserves a spot in your marketing swipe file:

1. They Made the Customer the Hero

By inviting fans to spot and report “ketchup fraud,” Heinz turned it into a movement. It wasn’t about policing—it was about protecting the flavor you love.

2. They Reinforced Brand Equity Without a Hard Sell

They didn’t say, “Buy Heinz.” They said, “We know you already love Heinz. Don’t settle for imposters.”
It’s loyalty-first marketing.

3. They Turned a Brand Risk Into a Cultural Moment

Most brands would hide this kind of issue. Heinz made it a meme-worthy conversation starter—free press, organic reach, zero defensiveness.

4. They Made Packaging Work Harder

This campaign didn’t sell a product; it sold the trust tied to the bottle itself. That’s brand asset leverage at its best.

Startup Takeaways: What You Can Steal from Heinz

Whether you’re selling software, D2C products, or services, here’s what startups can learn:

Turn Weakness Into a Narrative

Problems aren’t always PR risks—they can be brand moments.
Your vulnerability might be the story that earns trust.

Mobilize Your Loyal Customers

Don’t just “build community.” Activate it.
Heinz didn’t just have followers—they had field agents.

Own the Category

Heinz didn’t just say they were the best ketchup.
They positioned any ketchup that wasn’t Heinz as a fraud.
That’s aggressive category ownership—done playfully.

Embrace Print + Digital + IRL

This campaign wasn’t just on Instagram or TikTok. It showed up in print, in restaurants, on tables, and in conversations.
True brand playbooks integrate the offline with the online.

Final Thought

When your product becomes so iconic that people fake it—you’ve made it.

But more importantly, if you can call out that fakery without sounding defensive or desperate, you’ve won the branding game.

Heinz did just that—with a wink, a squeeze, and a brilliant call to action.

For More Startup Inspiration…

Until next time,
– Team Startup Stoic