- Startup Stoic
- Posts
- Borrowed Conviction: How Early Believers Shape a Startup’s Destiny
Borrowed Conviction: How Early Believers Shape a Startup’s Destiny
Every great company starts with borrowed belief — from someone who saw what others couldn’t.
In partnership with
The Power of Borrowed Conviction
Before product-market fit, before funding, and before headlines — there’s belief. Not always your own, but often someone else’s.
Every founder, at some point, survives on borrowed conviction. It might come from an early investor who takes a wild bet, a first employee who joins for equity instead of salary, or a customer who decides to trust a half-built product.
Their faith becomes fuel. Their perspective becomes proof. And their courage becomes contagious.
In the fragile early stages, when data is scarce and uncertainty looms, these believers don’t just validate your idea — they stabilize your confidence.
In this Startup Stoic Newsletter, let’s learn more about why borrowed coniction matters, the psychology behind it, and how it works for founders.
Find your customers on Roku this Black Friday
As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.
Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.
Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.
Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.
Why Borrowed Conviction Matters
Startups don’t grow linearly; they grow through moments of doubt, rescue, and revival.
When founders hit their first real wall — an investor rejection, a product crash, or a dry revenue month — it’s often someone else’s conviction that pulls them forward.
These believers:
Bridge your self-doubt when your own conviction runs low.
Magnify your narrative by sharing it with others.
Anchor your vision in reality, by offering perspective from the outside in.
As Ben Horowitz once said, “Every startup is a fight between faith and fear.” Borrowed conviction helps faith win a few more rounds.
Where Founders Find It
1. The Early Investor Who Bets on You, Not the Deck
Some investors back numbers. The rare ones back energy — your ability to figure it out. Their early belief signals credibility to others.
When Paul Graham wrote the first cheque for Airbnb, the founders were selling cereal boxes to stay afloat. He didn’t buy their business model; he bought their belief.
2. The First 10 Customers Who Stick Around
These are the ones who see potential before polish. They forgive bugs, share feedback, and act like partners. For them, it’s not about features — it’s about alignment.
Their testimonials, even if informal, shape your early reputation.
3. The Team That Joins the Mission
Employees who accept chaos in place of comfort are not just workers — they’re co-founders in spirit.
They amplify your conviction through execution. They bring stability to your swings.
As the saying goes: “A startup is a group of people who decided to believe the same delusion at the same time.”
4. Mentors and Advisors Who Lend Perspective
Sometimes belief is borrowed in the form of clarity. A single conversation with a mentor can reframe your approach and refill your conviction tank.
The Psychology of Borrowed Belief
Human conviction is contagious. When someone you respect believes in your potential, your self-doubt becomes less credible.
This psychological transference — of confidence, trust, and resilience — is what makes ecosystems thrive.
The inverse is also true: isolation erodes belief. That’s why successful founders surround themselves with people who see not what is, but what could be.
Borrowed conviction doesn’t mean dependency. It means energy sharing — a loop of trust that eventually becomes self-sustaining.
Turning Borrowed Conviction Into Real Momentum
Belief is borrowed early, but earned over time. Here’s how founders can channel it into growth:
Deliver Tangible Proof Quickly
Turn belief into validation. Even a small pilot, an MVP, or a handful of paying customers converts faith into evidence.Share Progress Transparently
Keep early believers in the loop. Updates turn them into evangelists, because they feel part of the journey — not just witnesses to it.Celebrate Small Wins Publicly
Every proof point — new client, new hire, new milestone — signals that the belief was worth it.Pay It Forward
Once your conviction becomes self-sustained, lend it to the next founder. Ecosystems grow when belief circulates.
The Stoic Lens: Faith Over Fortune
From a stoic standpoint, conviction is a discipline. It’s about mastering your reaction to uncertainty.
When founders borrow belief, they’re not surrendering — they’re collaborating with the collective energy of people who’ve chosen to trust them. It’s not weakness; it’s wisdom.
As Marcus Aurelius wrote, “If it is endurable, then endure it. Stop complaining.”
Borrowed conviction helps founders endure — long enough to find their own.
Final Thought: The Circle of Conviction
Every iconic startup carries traces of early faith — from people who saw the spark before the flame.
Over time, founders internalize that belief, turn it into proof, and pass it on.
That’s the quiet magic of startup growth:
A cycle of conviction, shared, borrowed, and eventually — earned.
Until next newsletter,
— Startup Stoic Team